6 Questions to Ask Before You Terminate Any Employee - performHR

Few leaders go into the employee termination process lightly, knowing that it’s a significant step. Will you be able to handle the process fairly, correctly and lawfully and without unwanted consequences? Given our experience in employment relations, we wanted to put together a quick guide to six questions you should ask before terminating any employee.

 

1. Have I done all I can to speak with and support the employee?

It may seem obvious, but it will be a waste of talent and resources to dismiss an employee who hasn’t had the chance to address any issues to do with performance or behaviour. Be sure to document and address any such issues, giving the employee plenty of time to improve before making the decision to terminate.

2. Is this a redundancy or a termination?

The two are handled differently and have different requirements, so it’s important to clarify the situation. Redundancy pay and other obligations will need to be considered if the employee’s role is ending, appropriate to their contract, the Fair Work Act and any applicable industry award.

3. If it’s a termination, does it comply with the Fair Work Act?

The Fair Work Act outlines essential rules and considerations that an employer must adhere to when ending employment, or you could potentially face a claim for unfair dismissal down the track. Employees must provide the employee with procedural fairness when undertaking a termination process. They must be given a valid reason and fair notice of the reason, as well as the opportunity to respond. Ultimately the reason and process for termination must be fair, clear and reasonable.

4. Could there be grounds for the employee to bring a claim for unfair dismissal?

In Australia a terminated employee may be eligible to bring a claim for unfair dismissal if they’ve been employed for over 6 months (12 months for a small business) and earn less than the applicable threshold, which is currently $158,500 and are not covered by a Modern Award. They may have grounds if the dismissal could be deemed harsh, unjust or unreasonable by The Fair Work Commission, which is why the correct process is so important.

5. What documentation and paperwork will I need to fulfil?

Depending on the reason and process for termination, there can be a range of documents to maintain and process. This may include a formal termination or redundancy notice, any written warnings, meeting notes throughout the process and proof of termination payment if applicable. It’s essential that this paperwork is documented correctly and appropriately for the situation.

6. Do we have the skills and understanding for this termination in-house?

This final question is important, because for many small to medium sized organisations the answer may well be no. Even larger organisations often choose to bring in an experienced, impartial third party to handle the termination process and ensure the correct steps are carried out. If you are currently looking for the right specialist team to support you through employee terminations and other workplace HR challenges, contact your closest performHR for outsourced HR services in Melbourne, Sydney and around Australia.

 

“Will you be able to handle the process fairly, correctly and lawfully and without unwanted consequences?”

Think People, think perform hr

Free Download

The ultimate HR eBook to benefit every business. Click here to learn more, or download the eBook for free using the form below.

    Our Valued Partners

    At PerformHR, we believe the best outcomes for our clients come from surrounding them with the right expertise.

    That is why we have built a network of legal partners who share our commitment to practical, commercially grounded advice.

    Together, we ensure your business is protected, informed and positioned to grow with confidence.

    Madison & Marcus Legal Advisory

    PerformHR has teamed up with Madison & Marcus, a highly respected and influential employment law firm, to offer our clients the best possible employment and safety advice. Our proactive and practical approach ensures that you receive professional guidance that is tailored to your specific needs. Trust us to keep your business protected and compliant with the latest laws and regulations.

    Visit website >

    Norton Rose Fulbright

    PerformHR has partnered with Norton Rose Fulbright, one of the world's leading global law firms, to ensure our clients have access to sophisticated legal counsel when the complexity of a matter demands it. With more than 3,000 lawyers across six continents, Norton Rose Fulbright brings international reach, deep sector expertise and enterprise grade advice to every engagement.

    Visit website >

    Coleman Greig Lawyers

    PerformHR has partnered with Coleman Greig Lawyers, one of Sydney's most respected and long-standing mid-sized firms, to deliver practical, industry specific legal support to our clients across NSW. With nearly a century of experience and deep roots across Western Sydney Australia's third largest economy, Coleman Greig understands the real world pressures facing SMEs, family businesses and growing enterprises. From employment law and commercial agreements to franchising and compliance, their team delivers tailored advice with the expertise of a large firm, and the genuine client focus that sets them apart.

    Visit website >

    © 2026 performHR. All rights reserved. Privacy Policy | Sitemap.