Three Tips For Having Salary Review Conversations | performHR

July and August are naturally popular months to conduct performance reviews – and unless you have managed to shift perceptions in your business, with performance reviews come an expectation of a salary increase.

This can leave businesses in a tricky position. A performance review doesn’t have the same effect when the employee is waiting to find out ‘how much’.  Whichever way it goes, it’s likely to overshadow and relegate the content of the conversation.

So, decouple your performance reviews from your salary conversations, and ensure your remuneration review strategy is fair, robust and realistic by following these three key steps.

1. Plan, plan, plan

HR teams should start planning and having conversations as early as possible.  This involves talking to managers about any roles that had a notable change and allowing enough time to benchmark to the market. Your planning should also include:

  • Setting deadlines and communicating these to managers
  • Allowing time in your plan to follow up and ‘vital’ conversations
  • Communication strategy
  • Ensuring everyone in the business is aware of the process, including your team
  • Encouraging managers to be open with employees regarding their remuneration and be transparent with market data if available.

Consider creating a table template that aligns how individuals have performed, with their position on your salary bands, in the context of what the organisation can afford to pay. This will create a strong basis for leaders to make fair, equal and informed salary decisions.

2. Dot your I's and cross your T's. Twice.

Again, a simple tip; however, you would be startled by the statistics on how many errors are made in the remuneration review process in organisations each year. It is HR’s role to ensure that everything and everyone has been covered.  Check, double check, and then check again all documents, letters to be issued, and notifications to payroll.

It is important for all employees to be educated and involved in the remuneration review process, and all employees should also receive a review letter, even if the employee is not receiving an increase.

This shows consistency but also makes sure the employee understands the reasoning behind not receiving an increase and provides a record of the review. HR should follow up with managers to ensure that all letters have been distributed.

3. Engage your team in the process

The most critical (yet most commonly overlooked) aspect of a successful salary review process is not just managing employees expectations, but more importantly: their engagement in the process.

Once you have an approved remuneration framework for making decisions, this should be transparently communicated throughout the organisation.

If your people are confident in the process they must undertake in order to receive a salary increase, both leaders and HR team can manage their expectation and perceptions regarding fairness in the process. This has a huge impact on employee satisfaction and performance.

Engaging employees in the process by incorporating a self-assessment, and multiple opportunities for open feedback and discussion, and transparency regarding timeframes are simple actions to ensure a higher rate of engagement and successful completion of the remuneration review process.

tips for salary review conversations

“The most critical aspect of a successful salary review process is not just managing employees expectations, but more importantly: their engagement in the process.”

salary review conversation

Think People, think perform hr

Free Download

The ultimate HR eBook to benefit every business. Click here to learn more, or download the eBook for free using the form below.

    Our Valued Partners

    At PerformHR, we believe the best outcomes for our clients come from surrounding them with the right expertise.

    That is why we have built a network of legal partners who share our commitment to practical, commercially grounded advice.

    Together, we ensure your business is protected, informed and positioned to grow with confidence.

    Madison & Marcus Legal Advisory

    PerformHR has teamed up with Madison & Marcus, a highly respected and influential employment law firm, to offer our clients the best possible employment and safety advice. Our proactive and practical approach ensures that you receive professional guidance that is tailored to your specific needs. Trust us to keep your business protected and compliant with the latest laws and regulations.

    Visit website >

    Norton Rose Fulbright

    PerformHR has partnered with Norton Rose Fulbright, one of the world's leading global law firms, to ensure our clients have access to sophisticated legal counsel when the complexity of a matter demands it. With more than 3,000 lawyers across six continents, Norton Rose Fulbright brings international reach, deep sector expertise and enterprise grade advice to every engagement.

    Visit website >

    Coleman Greig Lawyers

    PerformHR has partnered with Coleman Greig Lawyers, one of Sydney's most respected and long-standing mid-sized firms, to deliver practical, industry specific legal support to our clients across NSW. With nearly a century of experience and deep roots across Western Sydney Australia's third largest economy, Coleman Greig understands the real world pressures facing SMEs, family businesses and growing enterprises. From employment law and commercial agreements to franchising and compliance, their team delivers tailored advice with the expertise of a large firm, and the genuine client focus that sets them apart.

    Visit website >

    © 2026 performHR. All rights reserved. Privacy Policy | Sitemap.